September 6, 2006
-
Let’s talk about something, okay? Great!
It is impossible to know because it can in no way be measured, but I would speculate that this generation’s children have less imagination than the last generation’s did.
When I was growing up I was homeschooled, and each day when my friend finally came home from school we would go out and play army. It was worth more than you may think, creating entire worlds all for the sake of traveling them and finding the unknown — which was whatever we invented when we felt like it. Honestly we invented creatures, worlds, weapons, scenarios, identities — basically everything. We walked lands you have never seen. It wasn’t a shallow, one day mission either. Most of the time we would start a scenario one day and build on it througout the week, adding nuances to enhance the experience, often resulting in complex situations; sometimes we drew or used maps to show how enemy advances were progressing. All we had were our toy guns. The rest we imagined.
My little brother is nine years old and has never played army. He has beaten a plethora of computer games, some of them multiple times, and could probably recite the programming schedule for Disney and Nickelodeon from 3 PM all the way 10 PM. I would not blame him entirely — I hang out with him a lot, but other than that he has only one friend (which is all I had, but we got along really well) and is otherwise forced to do what he can around the house, which usually means watch TV or play on the computer. Watching television, outside of the educational channels, is one of the lowest forms of activity on the planet. And he does it for hours and hours — this is his childhood. Some movies he has watched 10 or 11 times. Over the summer he watched The Two Towers five times. A good movie, but it fosters no more imagination to watch it a second time than it does to go and “play outside” (ahh, that phrase dominated my childhood). His childhood is the exact inverse of mine: in my younger years all I longed for was to get the A-ok from a parent to call my friend to play. I learned to use the telephone when I was probably about eight and this conversation probably occured thousands of times until fizzling out around age thirteen:
(Riiiiing)
Parent of friend: Hello?
Me: Hi, is Alex there?
Parent of friend: Hold on.
Me: Ok.
Alex: Hello?
Me: Hey, wanna play?
Alex: Let me see if I’m allowed.
(A few moment go by)
Alex: Yeah, I can!
Me: Sweet, your house or mine?
Alex: You can come on over here.
Me: K, bye.After this, anything was game. Oh, the times! While my childhood flipped between being allowed to “play” and being grounded, my little brother’s flips between the computer and the television. I try to help. Sometimes while putting him to bed at night I ask him to give me three variables: person, place, and thing. With them I produce a story that implements each variable. But I can only do so much. His childhood is shaped by multidinous circumstances. And here is the sad thing:
I think he is only conforming. Most kids are becoming more inside-oriented, closed off from the world of adventure I grew up in. Kids used to loathe school because they longed to be outside, to feel free to roam around the house, to create adventure in their backyards. Now kids loathe school because they long to be home on their computers, free to roam the internet, to roam the television channels.
This deprives them of imagination. Growing up exercising the imagination gives books their flavor (and it might support my theory that the number of book-readers is declining, which it is). Heck, growing up exercising the imagination gives life its flavor.
The imagination is just plain silly fun. The possibilities are up to the author: in class one day a teacher may be giving a wordy lecture, and I look around to see my classmates sinking in their chairs, so I start to imagine. Now it’s not just a classroom of kids and a teacher, but Switchfoot is in the front of the room, with a full set of instruments. They hesitate for only a moment, and then synchronize the start of the obnoxiously loud music with the landing of their jumps. The image comes in clear, and they rock their best hits only a few feet away from my teacher, who apparently has no clue that she is trying to give a lecture over the greatest lyrics in rock today.
Of course I don’t just go around imagining anything, anywhere. The imagination is not to be cloyed nor interfere with other important things. I wouldn’t want to miss all the lectures; education is vital too. Imagination is not meant as an escape from reality, it is an addition to it, meant for the innocuous benefit of exploring what our minds can conceive.
This is why I love Calvin & Hobbes and C.S. Lewis. The wonderful touch of imagination.
Choosing imagination means extending the possibilities. I might even believe that when people grow up without imagination they have the propensity to not listen to other people, and can’t imagine how things could work another way than their own.
Am I right? Are electronics influencing kids to lives of lesser imagination? To lives with less proclivity to love nature? To lives that are uninterested in the surrounding world? Is it as bad as I say it is? Are other kids like my little brother? Does a lack of imagination give people cold hearts? Are the days gone when kids had no criteria for friends, except that they have fun together?
P.S. Sorry if I cloyed the word “Imagination.”
Everything here is underdeveloped, these are just some thoughts.
“There are no days in life so memorable as those which vibrated to some stroke of the imagination.” – Emerson.
Comments (10)
It’s because no one has to do anything. They have other people to have an imagination for them. No one wants to read anymore…
You’re brother is insane… I loved making up things when I was little… I think I was my own friend there for a bit because I would just give random objects personalities… haha… I’m not weird… at all.
The educational channels are awesome! I will admit I do watch brain numbing tv after a long day of actual brain wracking, because it’s not to veg and not have to think.
You could have been my friend…! We loved when you would come play four square or power ball with us…
I did the same thing too… I memorized Dustin Scarpittis’ number… I think I still have it memorized… haha I dialed it that much.
You were grounded! Bad kid, eh?
Don’t let him get a cell phone… He reminds me of my brother… but my brother is going on 17… He was always one of those conformists…
I love your thoughts Phil, we seriously complain about this at our lunch table… if you had fourth you would be more than welcome to join.
And I hate to tell you, but Switchfoot does not have the greatest lyrics of the day… Good stuff… I will admit that I sing Meant to Live ALL the time… but… yea… not the best… haha…
I was more of the cowboys and Indians type. My brother and I had some old table legs and those were our weapons of destruction. We would climb onto the barn roof or playhouse and would shoot each other.
That’s when my mother stopped allowing us to watch westerns.
Parents. They had to go and spoil the fun.
mmm i liked this post a lot. remember when you, melody, and myself would play slaves? or those secret clubs you and i had together (the shark club, the stuffed animal club…etc) but we wouldn’t let melody in those ones, muah ha. i still have the paperwork from those times. good times.
I don’t really have the right to comment on this, because as a kid I suffered from excess of imagination – I remember going to the library every Monday, getting seven or eight books (young adult/children’s – Lloyd Alexander-esk) and reading them all the same afternoon. Me and my friends never “played” anything – we always “played make believe”. I was playing make-believe until I was almost fifteen. Yeah, I knew by then that it was time to move on – but I didn’t really know what else there was besides living in a made up world. Heck, some of our worlds were pretty good – we had a lot of practice – with really fabulous plots and characters…. but looking back, I wish that my idea of the world hadn’t been completely formed by 3rd rate young adult literature- fantasy where all the heroine’s have a “wild and elven beauty”, historical romances that taught me all sorts of ridiculous lies about “true love” that I’m busy trying to unlearn.
In imaginations benefit, I could have just as easily been lied to by the television, my friends parents, or a bad teacher… But balance is good. Everything in moderation, eh? But I do agree that kids today don’t seem to have the same ability to entertain themselves with a stick and a patch of mud. TV – the twentieth century’s drug of choice…
Electronics are the new vice.
yeah, but you can’t blame him,
mitchmurphy is a friend from germany
(he doesn’t speak english that well)
I’m glad (for me and my younger siblings) that I grew up w/o TV and not that many movies. We were creative, too – having an older sister instead of brother, my brothers and I didn’t play army, but we did play “Oregon trail” and “pioneers and Indians” and “natives in the jungle”, etc. And I spent hours reading, which inspired a lot of our different games.
Definitely electronics are influencing kids to have less imagination. Working this summer with kids who spend most of their time watching TV, I realize…they don’t know how to play. Without TV, there is nothing to do. They won’t read, build forts, play outside, build lego towns, or do anything like I used to. They don’t know how to make anything up. Like someone above me commented, they’re used to having everything imagined for them. It’s sad, imo.
I completely relate. Good post.
Yes. I had a friend like Alex. her name was Chelsey. only we didn’t play army. we played school and house and rode bikes and stuff. i also made barbie towns with different friends. boy was that fun. my little sister is also a lot like paul. she floats from the tv to the computer ALL the time. oh, but she is always on the phone too. she would be good at multitasking if only she took the time to realize that she has work to do that she could do in half the time since she is always watching tv or talking on line and talking on the phone. I can’t multitask like that, at least not very well. I always negl….oh right I’m on the phone! sorry I forgot my train of thought so good bye phil!
I think I’m going to raise my kids someplace else. Poland comes to mind.